« Police & the law | Main | Autumn, SAD and elections »

September 24, 2007

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451cbef69e200e54ee727b08833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Politics as prog rock:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

kinglear

You have to admit, though, that Yes were rather better.....

Bob B

But the Labour Party is always in conference mood. As Harold Wilson used to put it:

"The labour party is like a stage-coach. If you rattle along at great speed everybody inside is too exhilarated or too seasick to cause any trouble. But if you stop everybody gets out and argues about where to go next."
http://creativequotations.com/one/480.htm

Mark Wadsworth

What King Lear says, only Yes weren't 'rather better' they were absolutely fantastic until about 1978 (with the exception of Topographic Oceans, that really was dire). Genesis only managed one good song and that was "I can't dance".

I think the better analogy is between politics and pornography. Totally predicable and you know the ending.

Tim Footman

When John Reid leaves Parliament he's going to take over the drum stool in a Van Der Graaf Generator cover band.

Max

A colleague has just come back to work from covering the Lib Dem conference and is dreading the Tory conference. It turns out that she was propositioned over 10 times, had to physically remove a sketchy, sex-mad LibDem from her arm, and has formed the opinion that not only are these conferences unsafe for women (one perv was 45+ years her senior, older than her grandfather), but that the only reason people seem to be going to them is to have sex.

ian

the only reason people seem to be going to them is to have sex.

Isn't that the case with most residential conferences?

Larry Teabag

I think Pink Floyd may cause problems for your analogy here... all the same this may be the most insightful political blog-post I've ever read. So thank you.

Skuds

Ah but while the Clash and the Damned disappeared, and the Pistols sometimes reform to get a pension together Yes and Rush are still touring and Pink Floyd made front page news when they came together for Live 8.

So it will take more than a political new wave to rid us of party conferences.

dsquared

hmmm yes, good to see that those middle class prog rockers were swept away by punks like Joe Strummer.

Matt Munro

"the only reason people seem to be going to them is to have sex".

In that respect very similar to workplace teambuilding activities.

Have to say I'm not a prog rock fan but even I can tell the difference between Genesis and Yes.
BTW Pink Floyd don't count as prog rock, to be classified as prog rock none of the musicians must take drugs, if they do it's just rock, apparently.

Cheese

Funny how people criticize prog. Upper middle class? Hello? Joe Strummer was the son of a diplomat. While neither Jon Anderson or Rick Wakeman of Yes were rich growing up.
Irreleveant? If that was true there would be no one buying their records today.
White Boys? Hendrix was going to join ELP if he hadn't died (and growing up he was far poorer than those punk bands. Also all the fusion bands were multinational (fusion is a subgenre of prog, there are loads of asian prog bands.Do any black punk bands exist? Punk is pretty much white.
Illusionary? I could argue that the punk bands pseudo lower class image and pretending to be tough was illusionary. After all the Pistols in truth were just a boy band created by McClaren and not a real lower class group.
Get your facts straight.

lefty

Bravo for Cheese

I'm sick of hearing how transgressive punk was and how seminal it was to radical politics. The Clash were OK but I'll take the dinosaurs anyday...

Cheese

Well there were far more radical political prog bands such as the communist band Henry Cow, who created Rock In Opposition (RIO for short) with like minded communist prog bands because punk had made rock too commercialfor labels to sign more radical music such as Henry Cow, Univers Zero etc.
Funny that.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Why S&M?

Blog powered by Typepad