« Songs in F | Main | Insincerity versus instinct »

October 12, 2007

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451cbef69e200e54f0a881e8834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Negative credibility:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

dearieme

That's precisely my interpretation of the run on Northern Rock. A decade of the Loathsome Wee Twat had left even a bunch of pensioners assuming that the truth is that which is diametrically opposite to an official statement.

Pseudonymous

I think this is a bit of an overreaction. Everything you learnt at school was told to you by a servent of the state.

And yet, you believe most of it.

Certainly people are skeptical of statements made to influence the listener, rather than inform them - but there is nothing new about that.

Zorro

Chris, you are quite correct and Pseudonymous is quite wrong.

I being a cynical bastard have thought this way for around a decade but the general public are finally catching up with me...

This /is/ happening, you saw it when they interviewed people queueing up outside NR branches. They said basically if the govt was saying X then they believed NOT(X).

Z

Sage King

Wisdom of crowds in action...fancy a vote on capital punishment?

Matthew

Surely this isn't how NR played out? When the government gave a guarantee the crowds melted away. They didn't believe the bank's management, fair enough.

Will

"These might just be examples of counter-suggestion - and our rulers' ignorance of this shows how little they understand of human nature."

Oh... come on Chris! You're just a clever version of Naomi klein now aren't you Chris?

Have a heart. Maybe they are just human? You know? Not fucking economist, fuckwit automatons? Ever thought of that?

This 'managerial class' or 'liberal class of professionals'of whom you speak -- what is their social/economic basis? Professionals/managers are much too diverse to be called a 'class'. You being a 'Marxist' should surely know that? Maybe you forgot about all that shit when you became part of the very class you pretend to critique?

The master:

http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1842/free-press/ch06.htm
"It is well known that a certain kind of psychology explains big things by means of small causes and, correctly sensing that everything for which man struggles is a matter of his interest, arrives at the incorrect opinion that there are only "petty" interests, only the interests of a stereotyped self-seeking. Further, it is well known that this kind of psychology and knowledge of mankind is to be found particularly in towns, where moreover it is considered the sign of a clever mind to see through the world and perceive that behind the passing clouds of ideas and facts there are quite small, envious, intriguing manikins, who pull the strings setting everything in motion. However, it is equally well known that if one looks too closely into a glass, one bumps one's own head, and hence these clever people's knowledge of mankind and the universe is primarily a mystified bump of their own heads."

Been to hospital lately Chris? You should have those bumps checked out! And stop looking into your beer glass (or wine glass or whatever).

PS -- Fuck off all the right wing dickheads who comment here. You scum will pay the price eventually! Fuck you all!

Philip Hunt

Some more examples:

4. Countries with “Democratic” in their name invariably are not.

5. Government scandals. When the Prime Minister says that a minister has his full support, you know he will soon be sacked or resign.

Katherine

Will, please shut up. You are doing the cause of the left absolutely no favours at all. You are trolling, and no one likes that, whatever their political bent.

Will

katherine.

Fuck off.

tom s.

Philip - that's very close to Galbraith's Law: "Anyone who says he is not going to resign, four times, definitely will."

mat

"Fuck off all the right wing dickheads who comment here."

I haven't noticed any. Can you name some?

pommygranate

""Fuck off all the right wing dickheads who comment here."

Classy guy.

Chris - these aren't statements from managers, but from politicians. No one believes a word from politicians anymore.

dreamingspire

Yes, significant numbers of the ruling class have negative credibility, but I suspend judgement until proven true, and after that they get labelled one by one (lots of them already).

The comments to this entry are closed.

Why S&M?

Blog powered by Typepad