« Bonnie Tyler syndrome | Main | How not to write about stock markets »

February 24, 2014

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

SIS

People like to moralize in this way because it allows them to ignore how much systematic power issues influence their lives, either positively or negatively. In general, individuals don't want to be reminded of just how central the group is to their status or well-being, since it forces them to realize just how little they individually control directly.

pablopatito

You've missed one thing. Rooney supposedly wanted to leave for Chelsea because he didn't feel United were playing well enough, or winning enough, to match his ambitions. He wanted to leave for football reasons, not financial. Or so he said.

By staying at a club that aren't playing well, or showing much signs of being able to compete with Chelsea and Man City, you could argue he is putting money before silverware. So on those grounds, he is a fat, greedy bastard.

Many bankers (but obviously not all) may prefer to be teachers or politicians or priests, but choose the less satisfying and meaningful career for financial reasons. Is there not an element of greed in that decision? Is playing in the Europa League for £300k over playing in the Champions League for £250k not greed?

Luke

pablopatito

"By staying at a club that aren't playing well... you could argue he is putting money before silverware. So on those grounds, he is a fat, greedy bastard."

Maybe. But another interpretation is that he wanted to be satisfied that Manure/the Glazers are prepared to put their hands in their pockets to buy or retain other top players. So he insisted that they put their money where their mouths were to demonstrate that commitment. Now they're spending all that on him, it's wasted if they don't win something, so they might as well pay up to buy/keep others.

Lewis

All people are guilty of this - the left just think they are more open minded and of course they aren't, they just happen to favour the poor over the rich and the deprived over the privileged. So when they accuse the Tories of demonising the poor, they forget that they do exactly the same to bankers, Etonians and right-wingers

Sean

Who cares? I mean, really, who cares? There are far more important issues out there. poverty, invol. unemployment, access to health care, affordable housing, govt. waste, obesity, global warming, drugs, and homelessness, to name but 9. I just see ceo/footballer pay as, well, kind of, a non-issue really.

Socialism In One Bedroom

It becomes greed when said filthy rich bastard resists attempts to redistribute the wealth, e.g. threatening to move abroad when tax rates increase, employing accountants to defraud the state. If you are very well rewarded and still seek to avoid paying for care for the elderly and the disabled, among others, greedy bastard is one of the more resonable descriptions I can think of.

Martin Connelly

Great post, thanks

chris

@ Sean - I agree that footballers' pay isn't a big deal. But the issues you mention are strongly related to the fact that income inequalities are misattributed to morality rather than power. If the poor are considered lazy and the rich talented, there's less demand for redistribution. And the power of the rich is surely a contributor to social problems.

Socialism In One Bedroom

"If the poor are considered lazy and the rich talented, there's less demand for redistribution"

This is bordering on being a non sequitur, your belief that labelling someone greedy leads to the assumption that poor people are lazy. No such assumption can be made, other than by being ideologically driven.

But, of course the apologists for the system will always claim that the system is built on merit, that those at the top deserve their rewards and those at the bottom theirs. But the fact that Rooney earns in a week what others will never earn in their entire lifetime easily proves that what is going on has no rational basis in merit. No sane system of merit would ever result in these outcomes.

But when you have a system that results in these startling inequalities it breeds greed, envy, despair etc etc. These are real, concrete and material things, whether they are symptons or otherwise. This is where the 'Marxist' left go wrong.

Having said that, I have to say that I cannot detect any real Marxism on this site. Don't get me wrong you bring a unique perspective to many issues and certainly provide plenty of food for thought. So keep up the good work!

Igor Belanov

You're being incredibly naive if you think it was merely a matter of Man Utd making an offer that Rooney couldn't refuse. He and his agent have spent a great deal of time over past years threatening to leave the club. In the present circumstances, with Utd in their worst position for 20-odd years, the club's management clearly panicked and caved in. Given that there are at least 20 players better than Rooney in the PL, there is going to be an awful lot of wage inflation in this sector, while wages for many remain static. The root of the problem is that there is far too much money in football.

Zlatan

Something to note is that by signing a new contract Rooney's transfer value has now increased, as players with longer to run on their contract command a higher fee than those with little time left, due to the risk they could just wait and leave on a free. And not only that, but United now don't need to spend £[x]m on a replacement for Rooney, such as Mandzukic or Cavani, who would also command similar wages to what Rooney's now on.

Igor Belanov

They already have replacements for Rooney, they could have tried playing Kagawa and Hernandez more, and Januzaj is effectively an attacking player.
Where Man Utd are weak is in control of the midfield. They badly need to replace Carrick and Cleverley.

djb

they are blaming [the rich persons] salary upon his personal character rather than upon his situation.

yes personal character comes in when they use their wealth and "power" to prevent programs that would help the poor

(so they dont have to pay any more taxes)

The comments to this entry are closed.

Why S&M?

Blog powered by Typepad