Bryan Caplan is soliciting class autobiographies. Here's his. Here's mine.
I spent most of my first 18 years in the same terraced house in Leicester; it wasn't quite a 2-up, 2-down as it had a garden. Our neighbours were mostly working class - carpenters, mechanics - but increasingly Ugandan Asians displaced by Idi Amin.
Mum was a secretary; her dad was treasurer of a working man's club. Dad, and his dad, was a lorry driver. However, dad went to prison when I was five - after the contents of his lorry went missing - and mum and dad never lived together after then. I only saw him once a week. After his release, he set up a building firm, and did well. When I was 18, he bought a huge house in the country, though he later went back to prison for VAT fraud.
We weren't poor - though I don't know how much money mum got from dad. We (mum, me and my sister) had a two-week holiday every year, to the Isle of Wight. We never went abroad. The first time I got on a plane was when I worked in the City, and had to fly to Scotland to give presentations to fund managers.
I went to the local junior school, passed the 11+ (the only boy in my school to do so) and got a place at a grammar school. I never wanted to go; it was two bus rides to the other side of town, and I thought it was posh; my mates (quite gently) took the piss out of me.
School wasn't too bad, except that it forced us to play rugby rather than football.
I was quite a lazy schoolboy, but I got a bunch of O levels and, with Leicester's economy suffering in the 1980 recession, choose to stay on to do A levels; mum seemed to welcome the extra child benefit.
By this time, our grammar school had been converted into a 6th form college, as part of comprehensivization. This had the effect of generating greater class divisions than existed in the grammar school. Our 6th form was split between working class kids who liked Kraftwerk and the Human League, and posh ones who still liked prog rock. I have retained a visceral hatred of Emerson, Lake and Palmer.
I gave no thought at all to life after school until my history teacher, in front of a whole class, disturbed my reverie by telling me: "Oxford would have you like a shot"
He was right. And I became the first member of my family for 500 generations to go to university. Luckily, I did well in the entrance exam, so had none of the (ill-founded) insecurity that afflicts many working class students.
So, what effect did this class background have on me? It didn't stop me doing well financially after university. But there's a big element of luck here. I was lucky enough to benefit from selective education, lucky to meet great teachers, lucky to go to university when few did and so had a strong signal of ability. And I was lucky that, as I left university, there was big demand for technical-ish skills as the City was expanding.
Had I been a few years younger, I'd not have had this fortune. In this sense, I disagree with Bryan when he says "differences in ability and character are the cause of class differences". I'd stress the role of luck.
My background has held me back in some respects. I've always earnt more money than my mum. And my upbringing did not give me expensive tastes. As a result, I've never felt the need to earn more than I have.
Also, I've never had the imagination to see that I could do jobs that posher people do; I was 21 before I met a graduate who wasn't a teacher. When I was interviewed for my current job, I was asked: "why didn't you become a journalist straight after university?" My instinctive reply was: "the thought never occurred to me." Even now, some jobs - the more mainstream media or politics - are mostly closed to people like me.
Probably the biggest effect, though, of my background is social. I've never felt that l fitted in, always feeling that I owe my place, wherever I've worked, only to my above-average intellect. People only want me for my brain.
Does this make me resentful, as Bryan alleges of the notion of class autobiography?
No. Everyone is scarred by their upbringing. The only question is: how?
I find many of your posts fascinating and would therefore be interested in your intellectual biography. But you might argue that it's easily pieced together from your posts.
Meanwhile, may I trump your crooked father with my grandfather, the Irish slum-dweller?
Posted by: dearieme | May 29, 2006 at 03:52 PM
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0385333498/
The Sirens of Titan by Kurt Vonnegut:
Page 232:
"'I was a victim of a series of accidents,' he said. He shrugged. 'As are we all," he said.'"
Posted by: Robert Schwartz | May 30, 2006 at 06:08 AM
Thus Dorset Street (a guess . . .) makes worriers of us all. Actually, Chris, you seem refreshingly free of the "I did it, so you can too" sentiment which afflicts the 'self-made' in both private and public sectors.
Posted by: Chris Williams | May 30, 2006 at 10:42 AM
Thinking about it, if it was two bus rides to Wyggeston, that rules out the Belgrave Road, assuming that the 22 and 37 ran at time. Gypsy Lane?
Posted by: Chris Williams | May 30, 2006 at 11:31 AM
Chris - I lived just off Melton Road (Marfitt St). Neither the 22 nor 37 ran then; this was the late 70s.
Posted by: chris | May 30, 2006 at 01:27 PM
"I have retained a visceral hatred of Emerson, Lake and Palmer."
Me too, and that's completely without any class or other issues irrelevant to the quality of the music. For you, that may of added to the feeling, giving it a depth and quality that makes it worth savoring (no, not "sp?"), but the feeling itself originates in the quality of the music.
Posted by: typekey pseudonym | May 30, 2006 at 03:27 PM