« Competition vs safety | Main | Johnson, Burke & MPs' pay »

November 03, 2009

Comments

Diversity

The Tories have been painting themselves into this corner; though I find it impossible to credit that they intend to go there or that they understand what they have been seying on macro-economic policy.

The fun point is tha there is a logical way out - join the euro at around 1 euro = 1 pound, and the price advantage for UK goods and tradeable services could be sufficient to expand exports enough in the new, much bigger "home market" for our exporters.

Pity that all leading Conservatives bar Ken Clarke have ruled out joining the euro; and that Cameron has left all the major European Governemnts so distrusting of him tha they would not let him in.

Econoclast

I think the important thing here is that politicians have to be honest with the electorate. The economic 'miracle' of 1997-2007 has collapsed and the country now has to adjust to a fall in its relative living standards, just like the other 'overspenders' (the US, Spain, Ireland, Iceland).

That will involve cuts in public spending, broad-based tax hikes and some other mechanism. We might consider doing what Spain and Ireland will have to do, given that they are in the euro. They will have to deflate their domestic economies and accept much higher unemployment as a way of reducing their relative living standards.

Alternatively, we can do what most UK policymakers have done since 1967 - engineer a fall in the pound. This delivers the needed adjustment in real living standards without too much pain in terms of higher unemployment or lost output. But as you say, the pound will have to fall a long way to deliver these benefits. Perhaps our politicians should be more honest about the economic policy 'choices' we have.

Luis Enrique

Econoclast,

I think there's some truth in that. With a booming financial sector and a strong pound, we were able to import the productivity of (low wage) countries. If we are going to correct our imbalances (see Martin Wolf today: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/a7977fc6-c8c2-11de-8f9d-00144feabdc0.html ) we are going to have to live with a lower pound, and get by on our own level of productivity, and this could well mean a decline in material living standards. I'm not sure whether this scenario entail higher unemployment, though.

botogol

whatever the opinion (or hopes) of the Tories, the pound surely WILL fall, given the financial policy currently being pursued.

Look at this and tell me whether the pound is a 'buy' or a 'sell'
http://burningourmoney.blogspot.com/2009/11/worst-in-world.html

I jolly well hope the Tories are planning what to do in the event of a collapse in sterling.

Giles

But why should a large fiscal deficit lead to a fall in the pound? It may mean higher rates, and a higher pound. See the Reagan Dollar (I think).

Econoclast is right: lower currency values are sometimes a neat way of forcing down living standards, if that is necessary. But they can happen anyway: e.g. germany 2001 onwards.

The comments to this entry are closed.

blogs I like

Blog powered by Typepad