« The ballad of Kostas & Jurgen | Main | Stagnation: in the mind? »

November 25, 2013

Comments

Anthony

A lot of this particular type of boss class is not exclusively "capitalist", with some of the worst managerialism residing in the public sector.

Guano

"Which raises a paradox."

It's a paradox that's been hiding in clear view since at least 1968. The Establishment view then was that exercising the right to free speech would lead to totalitarianism, or that those demanding free speech were totalitarians.

I think the justification of this point of view is that if we had too much free speech that would lead to chaos and then that would lead to totalitarianism. The answer to that is, I suppose, that the current system must be pretty weak if free speech leads to chaos.

chris

@ Anthony - of course you're right. The thing is that the public sector is taking its managerialist mindset from a capitalist model. (I was thinking of capitalism in the sense of "top down" control, rather than private sector markets)

Anonymous

Could not agree more !

With NSA and GCHQ spying on all and sundry, how can we be a free people?

The Money Laundering Regulations now effectively mean that all transactions need the approval of the police.

Dare to speak out in the work place and you are likely to be "managed" out of the organisation.

If you challenge the consensus then you have an "attitudinal problem".

I fear the blunting of the national IQ which such intellectual repression and conformity produces will not assist the country's future prosperity.

Rant over

dongately

"The thing is that the public sector is taking its managerialist mindset from a capitalist model."

yes and no imho - so yes in that for example far too much public sector project management is informed by the Prince2 approach - originally designed to project manage IT contracts but now applied to the broad range of services including far too much social care. The need to work this way is tied into many contracts so that large chunks of civil society are now aligned to this approach.

Even then there is a specific public sector approach which comes from a paternalist pov. It has commerce related trappings and perhaps commercial approaches gave this approach a new language and structure but I don't think it can be blamed on capitalism as it has a deep foundation in the faith in the state to intervene as an external force in order to "fix" people and a lack of trust in collectivist approaches.

FromArseToElbow

The public sector has always been prone to managerialism, but it did traditionally operate in a pluralist environment, having to balance the competing demands of Whitehall, local councillors and the unions.

The last 30 years have seen that environment whittled away, largely replaced by a "commercial" relationship between central government and large private companies.

Prince2 was created as a filter for public service outsourcing (IT was the first place they started). It prevents smaller businesses from competing with the favoured suppliers who have made its manipulation a core "skill".

It adds nothing to vanilla PM best practices and has few fans in the private sector beyond ex-public cartels that lack the competitive pressure to change (e.g. the utilities).

Jim

Its not so much that 'Marxists were the totalitarians and capitalists were on the side of pluralism' (or the other way around) but that the people who like telling other people what they can and can't do stopped pretending to be Marxists, and now pretend to be capitalists. They just wanted to tell people what to do so joined the 'winning' team to be allowed to do so.

Churm Rincewind

What was it you were saying the other day about inferring too much from individual examples?

I fail to see how a small number of anecdotes amount to any substantive evidence for "the decline of British Universities", let alone the triumph of totalitarianism.

Phil Beesley

@dongately: "yes and no imho - so yes in that for example far too much public sector project management is informed by the Prince2 approach..."

Prince2 (is it not becoming Prince3?) defines project management practice in the public *and* private sector. It might work for some, where it is possible to assess risks based on past experience, when a project is like something that has been delivered previously.

Ironically, given its roots, Prince does not work well in IT. Few IT projects are a rework of something that the company previously delivered; the desired product is complex and demands multiple inputs. It is not the IT of PrinceX.

Keith

It has always been a conceit of the right that they believe in freedom. But their version is very selective.

Socialists and social democrats in europe have a much better record as regards freedom. But Blair and his cronies have made the mainstream left party less liberal in various ways mixing up the picture.

monclerphalangere

moncler jackets from the brand name report from the ethnical marketing procedure, you use not one but two modalities, a single function connected with professionals should help firms earn the street Growth Course of action and type lots of model resources to supply interesting

ConoBogspenna

ugg teva sandalen kinderen

Unique shoes and ugg boots
Most individuals could feel of the UGG bootsFolks could feel of the ugg bootsThus replica handbags for saleit is taken into account cheap Balenciaga Medium Giant Part Time in Bronze Gold 084439-14to be a budget Louis Vuitton Handbags M5208Hmust-Have color this replica bagss Hermes replica pursese replica affordable wholesale handbags Gucci Bi-Fold Wallet 152619 for saleseason with a cheap Miu Miu replica handbagscollection in gray replica handbags monogrammed Canvas Bucket Bag Small M42238 for salecolor. Usually, Bags reproduction-Handbags-Outletin the dusty Miu Miu salegray color is cheap Chloe for saleone of my replica handbags Gucci Small Messenger Bag Sand 189749 for salefavorite since they replica handbags Damier Canvas Pochette Wallet N61724 for saleare easily fit replica handbags YSL Downtown Large Tote Dark Coffee for saleand works with Chloe replica handbagsany occasion. Instead replica handbags Monogram Mini Lin Danube M95228 for saleof the black replica handbags Thomas Wylde Suncross artist Medium Bag Black for salecolor, Gray makes imitations handbagit more seasonally Coach replica handbagsversatile than a Bally replica handbagsblack bag. In addition to the 3 control key essentials absorbed upon the increas bear your foot warm and dry without worring about fabulous cool and a solid wind. However this sneaker isn't are made as waterproof shoe, It for the other hand can safeguard your foot from puddle. Because of ease and comfort and serenity to carry out you delighted and free, ugg boots are rage all making use of the world, From house organize pump motor time for global markets, As well as certainly not only a few entire time subsequent to pizzazz change. Your identical, Timberland boots so cool, This look of snow boots, Having it. a warm and methods to find a way, red, Grayscale some dark colors, Just much such as men in the bar leader. Nike sportswear and casual clothes like all the other makers also shows that the relaxation of life disposal. You produce a special style statement of the basic skills, Unique shoes and boots.

ugg sandalen mayla

ugg youth sizes

sypeGyclesk

canada goose jakke norge
?Kommentar av Canada Goose Coats October 9, 2011 10:10 pmIt fryktelig ? m?tte se et nordsiden uttak som jeg anser nesten som en s?ster gr?te ?ynene ut som hun blir tvunget til ? si farvel til sin lille s?ster og hennes mor, sa Perez, 15, som bor sammen med sine foreldre og eldre bror i forstaden BirminghamIt er i utmerket conditionMy gjette p? verdien av en bl? fjellet keramikk gooseIs 15 dollar til 50 dollar alt avhenger av ? finne en kj?pers det uttales Canada Goose Gjess eller kanadiske Goose Geese.Tags: canada goose outlet, moncler pas cher, billige cialis onlineChoosing The Best Quilted Jacket Av: Patricia Shinkaruk N?r h?sten kommer, og man innser at t tid t cnidr hi r hr ytre antrekk fr th kaldere ?rstider, vattert jakke ma ome til pleier mindMost av disse moncler jakker ? v?re bestselgeren i USA, initiativ, STORBRITANNIA sammen med vesteuropeiske places.Although gjennomsnitt bare 16 inches h?yt p? skulderen, disse kompakte jakthunder er sterke nok til ? b?re en voksen Canada Goose, if?lge Encyclopedia av Dog BreedsAs en av mange store plagg produsent, er Canada Goose Corporation kjent for h?y ytelse Canada Goose apparelComment av canada goose jakke 26 oktober 2012 06:44 pmThis informativ artikkel oppn?dd gode resultater meg, er thanksThe canada goose nettbutikk Canada Goose ned pels jakke ofte en frakk som gir funksjoner n?r opprettholde design og comfortCanada Goose Outlet Forbedret terapi for ejaculation.I039, ve bodd her hele mitt liv, s? jeg vet hva en Canada Goose ser liker, h?res ut som, og hva they039; re flokker atferd b?r se like.Tags: canada gooseparka, canada goose salg, canada goose online, canada goose, parkFind canada goose Out All Over Caribou HuntingBy: Maryann Lapitan Caribou jakt er en eksklusiv kompetanse i flere factorsTags: Canada Goose down parka, Canada Goose Expedition Parka, A klart nei fra meg, er jeg sikker p? at det finnes kj?pere som venter, men de bare trenger ? se en definitive spor for 3D TV.Usually m?ter vi n?re venner i parken som kommer til et utvalg for ? f?lge oss mens vi f?rer gooseWhat er forskjellen mellom kanadiske g?s fj?r dyne og g?s fj?r dyne.

canada goose купить

canada goose купить

The comments to this entry are closed.

blogs I like

Blog powered by Typepad